On the masthead of this blog you will notice the beautiful bottle of George T Stagg, one of three whiskeys in Buffalo Trace’s Antique Collection. Selling for a hefty $50-$60 per bottle, the 2006 release is already nearly sold out. I still find a few bottles remaining on the shelves of well-stocked and upscale outlets, sometimes even locked in display cases, but they won’t be there a month from now. Distributors are getting stingy with their allocations, not only because this bourbon is in great demand for collectors and bourbon lovers, but also because they hate to see these bottles turning up on eBay auctions where they are often sold at a huge and probably illegal profit. Prices on eBay today range from $84.95 (plus $15 shipping) to $104.95. A rarer 2005 bottle is going for $109.95 and an even more uncommon 2004 release is $139.95.
Bourbon drinkers tend to feel strongly about this bourbon, dividing into two camps with almost no one in the middle. Either they hate it, considering an uncut, unfiltered bourbon simply undrinkable. Others—myself included—love the full oak and peppery finish of this chocolate thunder. Some choose to proof it down by adding water, but I prefer to sip an shot of this throughout a relaxing evening, never proceeding to the next sip until the explosion of flavor in my mouth has subsided and the taste is completely gone.
George T Stagg is probably my favorite premium bourbon, but because Buffalo Trace releases it so infrequently I have to stretch it out throughout the year. As soon as it was released in the fall I bought as many bottles as I could justify and will savor them throughout the year. To sip Stagg is to savor the seasons of the state that gave it the flavorful fortitude that makes it unique. Uncut, unfiltered, unpretentious.
If you are lucky enough to find an outlet that makes the fact sheet that the distillery released with the bottles, you find the kind of stuff that avid bourbon fans love. Interestingly the 2004 release (which I believe was their first venture into the ‘straight-out-of-the-barrel’ market) was only (did I really say “only?”) 129 proof, but the 2005 and 2006 releases were 141.2 and 140.6 proof respectively. I still haven’t figured out why their would be a 6% alcohol content difference from one year to the next since they mix 89 barrels. All I can figure out is that the first year’s release came from a different part of the warehouse or was a different age than subsequent years.
The fall 2006 release was distilled in 1990 and aged for over sixteen years and when you roll this over your tongue you taste every temperature change that drew that whiskey in and out of the char in all 187 months. The deepness of the bourbon’s color is a precursor of the rush of taste that explodes when you sip it. The taste is shockingly caramel, palpably warm and oaky, and feels like it thickens into a light syrup swirling over your taste buds. If you have to proof it down you will still enjoy the flavor, but the robust peppery finish is part of the pleasure as far as I am concerned, Try just a little of it neat first and then make adjustments if you must. While I enjoy Booker’s, Jim Beam’s readily available contribution to the U&U market, Stagg far surpasses it for a memorable bourbon tasting experience. I love Stagg.
Here is the fact sheet from the good folks at Buffalo Trace:
GEORGE T. Stagg
Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Distiller
Buffalo Trace Distillery, Franklin County, Kentucky
Age Profile
Year of Distillation: Spring of 1990
Release: Fall of 2006
Release Brand name: George T. Stagg Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Proof for release: 140.6 proof
Recipe
Large Grain: Kentucky Corn; Distillers Grade #1 and #2
Small Grain: Minnesota Rye
Finish Grain: North Dakota Malted Barley
Cooking / Fermentation
Milling screen: #10
Cook Temperature: 240 degrees Fahrenheit
Water: Kentucky Limestone with Reverse Osmosis
Fermentation: Carbon Steel / Black Iron fermenter
Mash: Sour
Distillation & Aging
Distillation: Double Distilled; beer still and doubler
Proof off still: 135 Proof
Barrel: New, White Oak; #4 Char; Charred for 55 seconds
Barrel maker: Independent Stave; Lebanon KY
Barrel entry proof: 125 proof
Barrel size: 53 liquid gallons; 66.25 Original Proof Gallons
Warehouse: Warehouse I
Floor: 8th
Evaporation loss: 57.57 % of the original whiskey lost to evaporation
Bottling
Barrel selection: 89 hand picked barrels
Filtration: None
Product Age: 16 years and 3 months old at bottling
Tasting comment: “Like a big chunk of dark chocolate”
